I think it’s safe to say that I’m a fan of Lena Dunham.
Her debut film Tiny Furniture was a smart, self-effacing and refreshingly honest look at post-graduate insecurities and fears. It was lauded by critics and won the Best Narrative Award at the 2010 SXSW Film Festival. It was an introduction to Dunham’s voice and sensibilities, but I worried that it would be a one-off talent. I was wrong.
Her new series, Girls, tackles similar issues with the same tenacity that defined her previous work. It’s funny, uncomfortable and not above criticizing its four protagonists. Dunham excels in placing herself in awkward and compromising positions, and her commitment to being so uncouth is a large part of the show’s appeal. She’s a misguided brat with the best of intentions, and I would be hard-pressed to argue that she’s not the only 20-something with the same flaws.
The show has had its share of fans (it was lauded as “groundbreaking” by David Wiegand and the San Francisco Chronicle), but its passionate base of detractors have attacked the show on the grounds of nepotism, racism and a lack of realism. These are bogus claims, in my opinion, but they’re worth noting, especially for a show as fresh as this one is. Continue reading →